Darren Criss first stole our hearts with his role on Glee — and for some dedicated fans with his role in A Very Potter Musical — and not much has changed since. After wrapping the hit FOX series, the handsome actor has been keeping busy performing as the title character in Hedwig and the Angry Inch and even playing Prince Eric in the Hollywood Bowl’s performance of The Little Mermaid.
While we’ve certainly loved hearing his beautiful voice on stage, there’s a big part of us that misses seeing his equally beautiful face on our screens week after week. We are fully pumped to see him reunite with Glee creator Ryan Murphy for American Crime Story season two. In preparation for his return to TV, look back at how much more attractive Darren has gotten since saying goodbye to Blaine Anderson in 2015.